A pair of headlines from the Financial Times. From 3 February: “Silver’s runaway rally becomes ‘death trap’ for Reddit’s retail crowd”. And five days later: “Retail traders double down on silver even as price plunges”.

A contrast but hardly a contradiction. The same meme-driven momentum that fuelled enthusiasm during silver’s rally now underpins the ‘buy-the-dip’ sentiment just as strongly.

Sentiments & structures

It’s not just a question of investor psychology. There are different structural constraints, too. As the latter piece points out, while “violent swings have put off many institutional investors, who must work within risk-control limits and face margin calls … when leveraged bets go against them”, retail appetite, limited only by risk tolerance and available capital, remains strong.

For brokers, this can make retail trading behaviour harder to anticipate. Unlike institutional flows, which are broadly shaped by risk-control frameworks and a focus on fundamentals, retail activity is, to a greater degree, driven by sentiment, available capital and online narratives.

Nor is it as simple as “number go down, retail buys the dip.” The recent Bitcoin plunge, for instance, was marked not by retail bargain-hunting but by so-called whales accumulating BTC, something smaller investors lacked both the capital and structural incentives to do.

The macro view

It is not only investor behaviour that has become harder to predict. Market conditions themselves are unusually volatile. Established correlations can no longer be taken for granted, and the speed of recent moves makes market direction increasingly difficult to call. When both retail behaviour and market conditions refuse to follow predictable patterns, brokers find themselves navigating uncertainty on two fronts. Managing risk now means navigating both the macro forces shaping markets and the sentiment driving retail trading, which means that brokers need to think about risk more holistically.

In volatile markets, partnerships matter. As uncertainty grows across both structural and behavioural fronts, the right support becomes essential. Get in touch with Finalto to learn more about our award-winning liquidity solutions and industry-leading proprietary technology.

All opinions, news, research, analysis, prices or other information is provided as general market commentary and not as investment advice and all potential results discussed are not guaranteed to be achieved. The information may have been derived from publicly available sources, company reports, personal research, or surveys. Past performance is not indicative of future performance. Trading carries risk of capital loss. Service available to professional clients only.